Muller's is Chincoteague's oldest and finest ice cream parlor, housed in the historic 1875 Cropper House in the old part of town. The owners, retired teachers from Pennsylvania, serve old-fashioned soda fountain treats in a Victorian setting. Muller's is the only dip shop in Virginia serving Bassett's, America's oldest continuously produced ice cream. They also serve real soft serve custard, fruity Dole Whip soft serve, Italian Water Ice, draft root beer right from the keg, frozen Greek yogurt, and fresh fruit sundaes, and Belgian waffles with ice cream , fresh fruit and homemade whipped cream. Return to another century. Come visit our candle-lit porches on a warm summer's night.